Here is a link to a great article on understanding the problem with religious pluralism. If all you have is a very surface view of religions (including your own) it is very easy to assume a pluralistic view. But a careful study of religions logically shows that they can not all be right. There are some good comments below also. I am very much in the Kierkegaard camp with the possibility of a middle way. I believe that Scripture does make an exception without stripping away the exclusive claims of Christ.
RELEVANT Magazine - It's OK to Say Jesus Is the Only Way